Papa Johns Pizza

I want to start with: I NEVER post reviews on restaurants. AND: We are usually very happy with Sparta’s Papa John’s. But not last night.. Our order was on its way, when the driver called to inform us that our cheese sticks didn’t make it in her car and she’d have to go back to get them. So, then it took 20mins for us to receive our order and of course the pizza was starting to go cold. But the cheese sticks the driver went back for… ended up being the most poorly put together “cheese” bread/ sticks I’ve ever seen. I just couldn’t believe the driver didn’t check them after going back for them. We call to complain and they give us $4 in papa John’s credit. Couldn’t even cover the entire cost of the cheese bread.

1/18/2025

Papa Johns used to be low on my list of local pizza places, but we found ourselves ordering pickup a couple weeks back. To our surprise, it was really good! I'm not sure if they have new management, employees, or what happened but something definitely improved. We liked it so much we ordered again a few days ago. Same quality as a couple weeks ago. I'd suggest to anyone that has wrote them off previously, give then a second chance. We're glad we did!

4/9/2024

some employee named Issac made my pizza 10/10, so many topping dominos can’t compete with this dude.

8/15/2025